Category: writing

  • Historical authenticity, historical verisimilitude, and how political correctness leads to bad Christian fiction

    3 months ago, Daniel Abraham wrote an article on historical authenticity in fantasy.  A week later, Black Gate blogger Theo posted a critique of that article (and a follow-up post 2 weeks after that, to clear up some of the misconceptions created by his initial post).

    Now I’m finally getting around to saying something about it.  I will clearly never be one of the top bloggers, since by the time I’m ready to weigh in on the latest controversy, everyone’s forgotten about it and moved on to something new.

    As I understood it, the gist of Abraham’s article is that when people criticize particular fantasy novels (usually ones “set in an imaginary medieval Europe”) for being sexist and/or racist, responding with “but the Middle Ages really were sexist and racist” constitutes an inadequate argument.  None of these fantasy novels, Abraham argues, present a historically authentic picture of  medieval Europe, so to say that they have to embody historically authentic medieval social mores is ridiculous.  He doesn’t say that they shouldn’t (although a few of the approving comments following his article seem to).  In fact, he explicitly states that, “There are legitimate reasons for racism, sexism, and sexual violence to be part of a fantasy project”.  Just don’t go saying that the simple fact of a story being set in a pre-Industrial society justifies their presence.

    Theo’s initial response to the article seems to be directed at the comment thread, not against anything Abraham actually wrote.  “We need less authenticity in fantasy?” he asks.  It’s also unclear that he gave Abraham’s article a close reading rather than just skimming for things he disagreed with.  “Abraham’s second point [that many classic fantasy novels would not be improved by more historical authenticity] can’t be addressed unless he provides us with some examples,” he says.  Fortunately, Daniel Abraham makes an appearance in the comments thread following Theo’s post, helpfully reminding Theo of the examples he does, in fact, provide.

    Theo’s follow-up post was better, and I agreed with much of it.  He agrees with Abraham that not all fantasy needs to be historically authentic, but expresses some concern over the idea that historical authenticity doesn’t matter for novels that are attempting to present some fantasy version of Europe’s medieval period more realistically (George R. R. Martin’s series A Song of Ice and Fire, for instance).  But he suggests that perhaps verisimilitude is a better word than authenticity:  that an author should “make a reasonable attempt to either a) get things reasonably correct, or b) provide the reader with some modicum of a rationale for departing from the realm of historical fact and plausibility.”  Just because it’s fantasy, in other words, doesn’t mean you can (or should) make up whatever you like.

    Although I tend to agree, I still think Theo is talking past Abraham here.  Abraham is saying (my paraphrase), “Don’t defend offensive content in a work of fiction by saying that the author is just being historically authentic.  If you think it’s defensible, defend it some other way.”  Whereas Theo is making a case for why fantasy fiction about imaginary pre-Industrial societies should be plausible based on what we know of how similar societies actually worked (even if that makes stories set in those imaginary societies offensive to some modern readers).

    Theo also laments the tendency to judge books on the basis of the political views that they appear to express:

    As it is created by intrinsically political creatures, all art may contain various political biases and perspectives, but that does not make politics an appropriate lens through which its artistic value is discerned.  If that is the route the genre is going to go, Tor may as well simply place donkey or elephant stickers* on its books and thus ensure that no one will accidentally read anything that offends their delicate political sensibilities.

    Hear, hear!  (Although the sentiment does seem a bit ironic, in light of the irrelevant attacks on Keynesian economic theory with which Theo introduces his original response to Abraham.)

    The comment threads following both Abraham’s article and Theo’s original response are worth reading, though there’s more of an actual back-and-forth dialogue following Theo’s post.  Most of the people commenting on Abraham’s article did so to vociferously agree with him and other commenters, and take his argument further than he did.  I found many of these comments insightful, but some of them bothered me.

    Here’s a sample:  “Strong female role models are important.”  “We like [generic Western fantasy], more than we should.”  “Generic epic fantasy wasn’t forced on us, we chose it as a model … It is not bad manners to question those authors who haven’t found reason to cut away its rotten pieces, [which] we’d all be better off without.”  “When you pick a few elements from the ‘default’ setting because they are right there … without examining what these elements stand for, you end up perpetuating the same old cultural hegemony, rather than making any kind of progressive statement.”

    This all starts to remind me of something.  The distrust of any fiction that appears to promote values that you disagree with, the skepticism about the value of any work that doesn’t explicitly advance awareness and acceptance of The Only Correct Way to Believe.  As a lifelong evangelical Christian, I can’t even count the number of times I’ve been told that, as Christians, we should only support the work of writers, musicians, and film makers whose work promotes Christian values.  Or heard Christian friends condemn particular books or films as morally bad.  I decided a long time ago that I was going to miss out on a great deal of interesting and powerful fiction if I was unable to appreciate books that I disagreed with (going back to Theo’s comment about donkey and elephant stickers).  And I don’t see why I should change, just because a different set of values is being held up by a different group as The One True Path.

    Also, anyone who thinks that encouraging and promoting fiction with “the right message” will lead to original and creative work should get themself to the nearest Christian bookstore, pronto, and take a look around.  It doesn’t matter what the message is:  if you convince authors that they need to make the correct political or moral statements in their work in order to be read and appreciated, every book starts to sound the same.

    As far as Daniel Abraham’s actual argument goes, I sort of agree and sort of disagree.  I sort of disagree because I think that most people arguing for historical authenticity actually mean historical verisimilitude.  They don’t really believe that “fantasy medieval Europe” is historically accurate, and they realize that the Middle Ages were more varied and complex in culture and social mores than our consensus picture of them would suggest.  So Abraham is making a bit of a straw man argument here.

    Also, although Abraham gives excellent examples of fantasy novels that don’t have much historical authenticity–or, arguably, verisimilitude–and don’t need it (The Chronicles of Narnia, The Last Unicorn, etc.), he ignores historical and pseudo-historical fantasy, of which Guy Gavriel Kay’s secondary world novels from The Lions of Al-Rassan onward are perhaps the most pertinent example.  And an example for which it’s far more difficult to make a convincing case that historical authenticity is beside the point.

    I do agree with Abraham that even fantasy purporting to show the Middle Ages like they really were tends to ignore fundamental aspects of actual history (the importance of religion, the fact that not so many people lived in cities, the absence of dragons) whenever it’s plot convenient.  So why is that okay, but they somehow can’t invent a society in which women and men are equal?

    Though I have to say, I’m only in partial agreement here.  I agree that works like A Song of Ice and Fire aren’t as historically authentic as many people say they are, which makes it questionable to use historical authenticity to justify the elements that some find problematic.  But I also find it irritating when too many characters in pre-Industrial secondary world fantasy think and act like agnostic, politically liberal 21st century Canadians, Americans, or western Europeans (or, even more irritating, when only the good guys do).  There is, in fact, a large percentage of the world’s population, historically and to this day, that does not share these values.  Isn’t it a kind of cultural imperialism to create imagined worlds where all the sympathetic characters agree with us on all the important issues?

    However, an argument is a bad argument if it doesn’t convince anyone, or even encourage them to look at the issue from a different angle, and it should be clear to those of us (including me) who have used the historical authenticity argument in the past that it isn’t convincing anyone who doesn’t already agree.  Abraham should be commended for bringing this to our attention, and for encouraging a deeper and more sophisticated analysis of fantasy.

    * For those of you who might be less familiar with U.S. politics, the donkey is a symbol of the Democratic Party, the elephant of the Republican.  Tor is one of the biggest publishers of fantasy and science fiction novels.

  • Story to appear in Canadian Best of the Year anthology

    The table of contents is up, so it’s official:  my story “The Kiss of the Blood-Red Pomegranate”, published last year in Aoife’s Kiss, is slated to appear in Imaginarium 2012:  The Best Canadian Speculative Writing.  Of course, I feel incredibly honored to have a story chosen for this, along with writers like Cory Doctorow, Geoff Ryman, and Peter Watts.

    Imaginarium is a yearly anthology co-published by ChiZine Publications and Tightrope Books.  It’s coming out in July, but you can already pre-order either the trade paperback or the e-book (Kindle, iBook, or Nook).

    I’ll post another update once the book has been officially released, and probably another once I’ve had a chance to read all the other stories.  This will be my first appearance in any Best of the Year anthology, so I’m pretty excited!

  • New story out in Nine

    My story “Clear Skies in Pixieland” just came out in the first issue of Nine, a brand-new e-zine.  If you’re interested, you can buy a copy of the magazine (or even a 3-month subscription) here.  The authors will receive royalties if the magazine sells enough copies, so if you buy one, you’re helping out the authors as well as the publishers!

    “Clear Skies in Pixieland” is a contemporary fantasy loosely connected to “The Kiss of the Blood-Red Pomegranate”, which appeared in the December issue of Aoife’s Kiss.  The shadowy villain mentioned in TKotBP actually shows up in this one.

    This is an important story for me, because it’s the first one I finished after deciding that I wanted to make a serious attempt at writing and publishing short fiction.  Before that, I’d mostly worked on novels.  I’d written a handful of short stories, even submitted a couple to magazines, but I’d give up after they were rejected two or three times (with those earlier stories, giving up was probably a good idea).  This was the first story I wrote after deciding that I was going to write short stories, and I was going to keep submitting them until they were accepted.  Perhaps unsurprisingly, the version that you can read now in Nine doesn’t bear much resemblance to that first version that I started sending around.  The basic premise is the same, but it’s been almost completely rewritten.  Twice.  As I learned more about writing, I would take another look at that old story, and realize that I could probably do better.  So I did.

    There are eight other stories in this issue of Nine (hence the name), one by Hugo- and Nebula-nominated author Ken Liu, who is also, coincidentally, one of my husband’s coworkers.  I haven’t read his story in Nine yet, but I really liked the story he had in last October’s Clarkesworld, “Staying Behind”.

    So, check out Nine!  Tell your friends.

  • Many worlds doesn’t mean what you think it does

    Unless you’re a quantum physicist, that is.  After years of listening to fantasy writers who haven’t studied any quantum mechanics using it to justify everything from magic to visitable alternate universes, my husband Donald (who did his PhD in quantum computation) finally wrote a blog post explaining how it doesn’t really work that way.

  • Go, elves!

    Those of you who know all about my love for elves will appreciate why I’m linking to this.

    Need I say more?

    Actually, I probably do.  Those of you who are not uber-geeks may not realize that it’s trendy within fantasy writer circles (and uber-geek circles) to look down your noses at any fiction containing the “e-word” as a blatant Tolkien rip-off.  Because Tolkien invented the word elf, right?  (Well, no, he didn’t, but never mind that.)  This whole anti-elf-snobbery irritates me to no end, especially since I’m trying to write an epic fantasy series with elves in it, which I don’t think is a Tolkien rip-off, and it would be nice if someone paid me money for it one of these days.

    What makes it even more irritating is that it’s apparently perfectly acceptable to have a physically attractive species of mystical long-lived hominids in your short story or novel, as long as you don’t call them elves.  They can even have pointy ears.  It’s just the word that pushes people’s buttons.  Seriously.  I have a short story that I’ve been trying to sell, in which one of the characters is an elf, and although it hasn’t been accepted, I have yet to receive any negative feedback from editors on that character’s obvious elfness.  Because in that story, I changed the name of his species.  I won’t tell you what I changed it to, but it still sounds a lot like elf.  Whereas when I do use the word elf in other short stories set in the same world (featuring the same elves), any feedback from editors tends to include disparaging comments about the elfness of those characters.

    I insist on using the word elf in some of my stories (and in my novel), despite obvious reasons not to do so, because I’m writing about cultures where humans have interacted with this other species for thousands of years.  If there were a real world where that were the case, I think the humans who had the most interaction would use a word that felt familiar to them.  “Elf” is the closest familiar English word to the type of alien people I’m trying to describe.  That’s why I use it.  (The story in which I used a different word has a human protagonist from a culture that hasn’t interacted with these folk nearly as much, so they seem more alien and weird to her; hence I decided it made sense to use an invented word instead of a familiar English word.)

    Anyway, go read the article I linked to on the Black Gate blog (and thanks to Donald for bringing it to my attention).

  • Courtney Schafer’s “The Whitefire Crossing”

    I recently finished reading the first novel by new author Courtney Schafer:  The Whitefire Crossing.  It was one of the free books I got at last year’s World Fantasy convention in San Diego.  I definitely recommend it, if you enjoy epic fantasy.  The plot is tight and suspenseful, the main characters are interesting, and the secondary world in which the story takes place is one you want to learn more about.  The premise is that a young smuggler named Dev takes on a dangerous job, trying to smuggle a runaway apprentice mage into a neighboring country, while being pursued by the apprentice’s furious master.  It ends on a not-quite-cliffhanger, where there’s a pause in the action but it’s also clear that Dev’s story isn’t finished.  But the back cover of the book does warn that it’s “Book I of The Shattered Sigil“, so that’s okay.  I definitely want to read Book II, to find out what happens next.

    While I did think the book was excellent, it did have a couple of flaws.  We’re told over and over (and over, and over) about Dev’s motivation for accepting such a dangerous assignment:  he needs the money to keep the daughter of his deceased mentor out of slavery.  But I thought this could have been shown more effectively, perhaps by drawing more parallels between the young girl in danger and Dev’s former lover, who was sold into slavery at a similar age (not in a creepy way; just in the sense of him not wanting the same thing to happen to his mentor’s daughter).  Also, the villains are cartoonishly evil, and I tend to prefer stories that explore the complexity of what makes someone evil (or good, or in-between).  But the characterization of the two protagonists (Dev, and the young apprentice Kiran) was complex and interesting enough that I could overlook those flaws, and the author used the alternating viewpoints very effectively to tell the two halves of the story.  As an author myself, I was definitely paying attention what Shafer was doing there; also to how skillfully she handed the unfolding of the plot and the building of dramatic tension.

    The cover, by David Palumbo, is also excellent, and is one of the reasons I chose to read this book over the half dozen other new 2011 novels I got for free at World Fantasy.  Not just because it was pretty, but also because it signalled pretty clearly what sort of book this was, and all other things being equal I’ll usually choose the epic fantasy novel first.  But the fact that the cover was attractive and professional-looking certainly didn’t hurt, nor did the fact that the book was published by Night Shade Books, one of the best-reputed medium-sized publishers of fantasy.  (These are all things that I think about as I write my own novel, and listen to the debates about self-publishing vs. traditional publishing.)  Though on the other hand, a few years ago I read a free-from-World-Fantasy novel published by Penguin, with a cover by a much more famous artist, and that book was awful.  (I’m not going to say which book it was, since my motivation in discussing books on my blog is to recommend books that I think people should read, not slag other hardworking authors.)

    It’s good to see epic fantasy being written by other women, too.  I don’t particularly seek out the work of other women writers; I read whatever interests me, no matter who wrote it.  But most of the big name authors in the field tend to be men, so it’s encouraging to see other women writing great fantasy novels and getting them published by major houses.

    If you’re a writer, Courtney Shafer’s website also has some excellent, candid information about the process of finding an agent and getting published, so be sure to check that out!

  • Today’s wordcount

    3300 words of novel written today!  I think 3800 words is my all-time record thus far, so I’m feeling pretty cheerful right now.  Of course, I don’t know how many of those words will end up staying in the final draft, and I think there are probably too many pixels devoted to characters worrying about what’s happening, telling each other important information that the reader needs to know, and too much about the wheelbarrow.  But, we’ll see.  It’s better than spending all my time on Wikipedia reading about ancient Roman swear words.

  • Top Ten Ways I Procrastinate from Writing

    Some writing sessions are productive.  Words flow from my fingertips onto the computer screen as quickly as I can think of them, and there’s nothing I’d rather be doing.  Other times … not so much.  Here are some of my favorite ways to procrastinate (number 3 was most apt, today).

     

    10.  Re-reading favorite parts of books I liked.

    9.  Catching up on e-mail.

    8.  Trying to get the armrests and seat height on my office chair just right.

    7.  Filing my nails.

    6.  Inventing complex back stories for secondary and tertiary characters who will probably be cut out of the final draft anyway.

    5.  Facebook.

    4.  Reading humorous articles my husband e-mailed links to, then following links on those pages to articles that are less and less funny, until 45 minutes have gone by and I’m watching a YouTube video that isn’t funny at all, wondering how I got to this point.

    3.  Research, research, and more research!  (“How can I possibly start writing a near-future science fiction story without learning everything Wikipedia can tell me about climate change, population trends, and peak oil?”)

    2.  Reading cookbooks.  (I’m not sure how many writers share this one, but for me it fills the role that for others is often filled by television:  entertainment that doesn’t require too much attention or engagement.)

    1.  Extra-long showers (“I’m clean now, but once I get out of the shower I’ll actually have to go work on that story.”)

  • Snarky writing advice

    From Nick Mamatas, ten bits of advice writers should stop giving aspiring writers.

    Though I wonder if it would be better to rephrase this as “Ten Bits of Advice Aspiring Writers Should Stop Listening To.”  I’ve received a lot of the advice on the list.  Some of it has been helpful, some of it hasn’t.  My advice is to ignore any advice that you think is wrong (including this).

    The comments thread for the article is also worth reading.  One point that comes up is that too much advice about the mechanics of writing (write likeable characters, don’t use adverbs, don’t use verbs other than “said” for dialogue, show don’t tell, go through and trim 10% off the wordcount once you think you’re done–that last one is one of my writerly advice pet peeves) can lead writers to produce stories that are adequate, but not very distinctive.  The best thing for your writing career isn’t necessarily to quash your individual voice and end up writing stories that are just like everyone else’s.

    Mamatas’s bottom line is that the only generally applicable advice for writers is:  “Write something publishable, attempt many times to get it published.”

  • “Looking-Glass Milk” now available in Kindle edition

    My science fiction story “Looking-Glass Milk” is now available to read on your Kindle or Kindle app.  This originally came out in 2009 from Scribblers & Ink Spillers as part of the Crystal Codices collection, but it’s out of print now, and I thought I’d re-issue it.

    The goal right now is to make sure that people are able to read all my published stories.  I probably won’t re-issue stories that are still available to read for free on the internet, since I want to encourage you to visit e-zines that have supported me by buying my fiction.  But for stories that came out in print, in magazines that are difficult and/or expensive to obtain, re-publishing old stories with Amazon seemed like a good way to make them more readily available.